DVD Cultural Diversity: Treating the LGBTQ "Coming Out" Conflict

Manual of Articles Sections 15 - 29
Section 15
The Diversity-Repressing Theory

CEU Question 15 | CEU Answer Booklet | Table of Contents | Homosexuality
Counselor CEUs, Psychologist CEs, Social Worker CEUs, MFT CEUs

According to the diversity-repressing theory for the benefit of sex, sex protects the genetic quality of the species. The diversity-repressing theory envisions that asexual species accumulate harmful mutations over time and gradually become less functional, as though asexual lizards gradually lost the ability to run fast or digest some food. Sex supposedly counteracts this danger by allowing family lines that have picked up harmful mutations to recombine, producing offspring free of bad mutations. According to this theory, some offspring will possess both families' mutations and will die even more quickly, but other offspring will have none of the mutations, and will prosper on behalf of the species. According to this theory, without sex each and every family line inexorably accumulates mutations, leading eventually to species extinction. Ending the Debate Although both the diversity-affirming and diversity-repressing views have a long history, the time has come for closure. The time has come to reject the diversity-repressing view as both theoretically impossible and empirically vacuous. The scenario envisioned by the diversity-repressing theory can't exist. In an asexual species, when a bad gene arises, the line where the mutation originated is lost to natural selection, whereas the lines without the mutation prosper. The entire stock never deteriorates, because natural selection doesn't look the other way while a bad gene spreads. Instead, natural selection eliminates a bad gene when it first appears, preserving the overall functionality of the species. No evidence whatsoever shows asexual species becoming extinct because of a progressive accumulation of disabilities and loss of functionality. A bad gene never gets going in an asexual species, and sex's supposed pruning of the gene pool is unnecessary and mythical. On the other hand, the environment does change from year to year, and individuals who don't do well one year may shine when conditions change, and vice versa. Butterflies whose enzymes work at cold temperatures thrive in dark, damp years, while butterflies whose enzymes function best at hot temperatures do better in sunny drought years. All butterflies are perfectly good butterflies, even if the abilities of some don't match the opportunities currently supplied by the environment. I don't see any grounds for dignifying the diversity-repressing view for the benefit of sex as a viable alternative to the diversity-affirming view. To be agreeable, one might say both theories are valid. But this compromise isn't true. Conceding, even slightly, that one function of sex is to prune diversity puts forth a view that hasn't earned its place scientifically. Accepting a diversity-repressing view of sex simply to be polite admits through the back door a philosophical stance that may later be used to justify discrimination. Therefore, I accept as a working premise that a species' biological rainbow is good-good because diversity allows a species to survive and prosper in continually changing conditions. I further accept that the purpose of sex is to maintain the rainbow's diversity, resynthesizing that diversity each generation in order to continually rebalance the genetic portfolio of the species. I reject the alternative theory that sex exists to prune the gene pool of bad diversity. Darwinists have to take a consistent stand on the value of diversity. They can't maintain on the one hand that most variation is good because it's needed for natural selection and on the other hand also maintain that females must continually shop for males with the best genes as though most genes could be ranked from good to bad. Instead, I argue that almost all diversity is good and that female choice is more for the best match than for the best male. How then should we assess the rainbows in our own species? We should be grateful that we do reproduce sexually, although we probably take this gift for granted. I feel too that we should conserve and embrace our rainbows. Affirming diversity is hard, very hard. We must come to accept ourselves and love our neighbors, regardless of color in the rainbow. Overall, sex is essentially cooperative-a natural covenant to share genetic wealth. Sexual reproduction is not a battle. -Roughgarden, Joan, Evolution's Rainbow: Diversity, Gender, and Sexuality in Nature and People, University of California Press Ltd: London, 2004 ================================= Personal Reflection Exercise Explanation The Goal of this Home Study Course is to create a learning experience that enhances your clinical skills. We encourage you to discuss the Personal Reflection Journaling Activities, found at the end of each Section, with your colleagues. Thus, you are provided with an opportunity for a Group Discussion experience. Case Study examples might include: family background, socio-economic status, education, occupation, social/emotional issues, legal/financial issues, death/dying/health, home management, parenting, etc. as you deem appropriate. A Case Study is to be approximately 250 words in length. However, since the content of these “Personal Reflection” Journaling Exercises is intended for your future reference, they may contain confidential information and are to be applied as a “work in progress.” You will not be required to provide us with these Journaling Activities. The article above contains foundational information. Articles below contain optional updates. Personal Reflection Exercise #1 The preceding section contained information about the "Diversity-Repressing" theory. . Write three case study examples regarding how you might use the content of this section in your practice. Online Continuing Education QUESTION 15 According to the diversity-repressing theory, what is the benefit of sex? Record the letter of the correct answer the CEU Answer Booklet.

Others who bought this LGBTQ Course also bought… Bullying: Preventing School Violence Bullying: Techniques for Dealing with Taunting, Teasing, & Tormenting Techniques for Teens Being Harassed by Cliques Teen Internet Bullying: Effective Coping and Prevention Techniques Bullying: Techniques for Dealing with Taunting, Teasing, & Tormenting Bullying: Techniques for Dealing with Taunting, Teasing, & Tormenting Bullying: Techniques for Dealing with Taunting, Teasing, & Tormenting Bullying: Techniques for Dealing with Taunting, Teasing, & Tormenting Bullying: Techniques for Dealing with Taunting, Teasing, & Tormenting Bullying: Techniques for Dealing with Taunting, Teasing, & Tormenting Teen Internet Bullying: Effective Coping and Prevention Techniques Ethical Boundaries: Treating Childhood Sexual Trauma It Wasn't Your Fault - Diagnosis & Treatment of Sexual Abuse Ethical Boundaries & Treating Sexually Abused Boys Conduct Disorders: Diagnosis & Treatment Juvenile Sex Offenders: Opportunity for Early Intervention Treating Dysthymia in Children & Adults with Cognitive Behavioral Therapy Fear of Feelings: Treating Male Suicide and Depression Diagnosis &Treatment of Male Shame & Depression Treating Post Holiday Let-Down & Depression Effectively Treating Pathological Self-Criticism in Depressed & Dysthymic Clients Postpartum Depression: Diagnosis & Treatment Diagnosis & Treatment of Male Shame & Depression Parenting: Teaching Parents Strategies for Difficult Teens Parenting Skills with Conduct Disordered Pre-Adolescents CBT Techniques for Building Client Self-Esteem CBT Techniques for Building Client Self-Esteem Physical Pain Stops my Pain - Treating Teen Self-Mutilation Interventions for Cutters: Substituting Self-Control for Self-Mutilation Understanding Motivation to Self-Mutilate

CEU Answer Booklet for this course | Homosexuality
Forward to Section 16 - Manual Article
Back to DVD Track 14
Table of Contents
Top

The article above contains foundational information. Articles below contain optional updates.

Michelle Obama snuck out of the White House to celebrate marriage equality with crowd outside gates - November 15, 2018
The First Lady dodged the Secret Service to join in the merrymaking the day marriage equality came to America as the White House lit up in rainbow colors.

Chad Griffin is stepping down as the head of Human Rights Campaign - November 15, 2018
After seven years on the job, Griffin will leave the organization on a high note.

Tanzania lost almost $10 million in foreign aid because of recent anti-gay comments - November 15, 2018
One of the biggest donors to Tanzania is cutting off aid out of concern for gay rights.

This ‘naked’ gay chef just landed his dream job… with Michelle Obama - November 15, 2018
"This has to be the greatest privilege... of my entire life, really. I’m over the moon!"

This trans man had never met another trans person – until Laverne Cox came to visit - November 15, 2018
What? We're not crying. You're crying.

CEU Continuing Education for
Counselor CEUs, Psychologist CEUs, Social Worker CEUs, MFT CEUs