Sponsored by the HealthcareTrainingInstitute.org providing Quality Education since 1979
Add to Shopping Cart

Immigrant & Refugee, Cultural Diversity & Ethical Boundaries: Freedom from Stereotypes
6 CEUs Cultural Diversity & Ethical Boundaries: Freedom from Stereotypes

Section 11
Model of Counseling: Bridging Brevity and Diversity

Ethics CEU Question 11 | Ethics CEU Answer Booklet | Table of Contents
Counselor CEUs, Social Worker CEUs, Psychologist CEs, MFT CEUs

Ethics - Multicultural Counseling
Although multicultural counseling is most often defined as a specialized practice that involves individuals from differing racial or ethnic groups, recent work emphasizes a generic definition that views multiculturalism as adiversity Cultural Ethics Boundaries social work continuing ed "fourth force" within counseling (Pedersen, 1991). Because all counselors and clients possess meanings, worldviews, and action patterns that reflect their sexuality, socioeconomic status, race, and culture, there is an important sense in which all counseling is multicultural. Shared by all multicultural counselors is a concern with the biases (Pedersen, 1987) and "cultural encapsulation" (Wrenn, 1985) that can result when professionals uncritically accept the assumptions of the dominant culture in which they practice. Although the specific practices of multicultural counseling vary from practitioners to practitioners--and, indeed, as a function of client culture (Lee & Richardson, 1991; Sue & Sue, 1990) and level of identity development (Helms, 1990; Parham, 1989)--a set of common understandings and practices seem to unite the field.

Validation of client identity and worldviews. Many practioners have noted that cultures are distinguished by distinctive sets of values end worldviews(Carter, 1991;Ibrahim, 1985, 1991;Sue&Sue, 1990). These perspectives help to shape clients' experience, forming a crucial part of racial and cultural identity (Helms, 1985, 1990; Parham, 1990). Recognizing that the dominant culture often devalues client worldviews and impairs the process of identity development, multicultural counselors are especially concerned with client validation and empowerment (Sue & Sue, 1990). This means that therapists must possess an awareness and knowledge of cultural differences, as well as skills that enable them to work within client frameworks (Pedersen, 1988; Sue et al., 1992).

Attention to the social context of presenting complaints. Many multicultural perspectives emphasize the role of "difference" in the genesis of client problems (Ramirez, 1991; Sue & Sue, 1990). Clients from ethnic and racial minorities have typically experienced expressions of prejudice, ranging from separatism and antilocution to discrimination and physical attack (Ponterotto, 1991). Indeed, multicultural counselors emphasize that it is the lack of fit between the minority client and the dominant culture--and not deficits internal to the client--that often generate presenting complaints (Ramirez, 1991). For this reason, multicultural therapists often function as social ecologists (Aubrey & Lewis, 1988; Conyne, 1987), addressing the needs of social systems as well as individuals (Herr, 1991).

Attentiveness to client distrust. Vontress (1988) noted:
[Minority clients] . . . have encountered so many historical and contemporary wrongs and hardships at the hands of white Americans that they tend to view whites in general with varying degrees of suspicion and hostility. Therefore, in counseling they are apt to be on guard against being duped or hoodwinked by people they have come to consider untrustworthy. (p. 349)

Such distrust may, in fact, account for why mental health utilization rates are lower and dropout rates are higher among minority clients (Poster, Craine, & Atkinson, 1991). An important skill of multicultural counseling is the ability to work nondefensively with this distrust and to build an effective therapeutic alliance (Pedersen, 1988). Ramirez (1991) described the multicultural counselor's stance as one of empathy projection "trying to understand the point of view and the feelings of someone whose values and cognitive styles may be very different from those of the therapist" (p. 54).

Ethics - Brief and Multicultural Counseling: Diverging Assumptions
Despite the aforementioned trends toward brevity and diversity in the delivery of counseling services, there seem to be important differences in the means and ends of these approaches.

Locus of client problem. An overview of the major approaches to brief therapy reveals that they tend to be derived from mechanistic and organismic developmental models that stress the acquisition of skills and insights (see Lyddon, 1989, for a review of developmental counseling models). These approaches view problems as internal to clients, resulting from the learning of maladaptive behaviors and cognitions and the disowning of important facets of the self. Multicultural approaches, conversely, are derived from contextualist models of development (Steenbarger, 1991) that posit problems as a function of poor person environment fit. Thus, client problems are not intrapsychic in this view, but instead are derived from a fundamental tension between the demands and resources of the environment and the needs of the individual (Herr, 1991). As Ivey (1985) noted, multicultural approaches inevitably address person and environment, including strategies for social as well as individual change. Brief therapies, in their relatively individualistic, intrapsychic conceptualizations, run the risk of disempowering clients by denying social causation and by blaming victims (Ivey, 1985; Pedersen, 1987).

Criteria of client inclusion. Brief therapies tend to target "high functioning" individuals who display circumscribed complaints of recent onset and who are capable of forming a rapid therapeutic alliance (Steenbarger, 1992a). Multicultural approaches, however, draw no such inclusive boundaries and, indeed, assume that clients will not be able to form a ready alliance because of past experiences with prejudice and oppression (Sue & Sue, 1990). Whereas brief therapies tend to view difficulties in alliance formation in terms of client "pathology," multicultural approaches link these to such contextual factors as economic status and social class (Vontress, 1988). This difference may help to account for the observed tendencies of helping agencies to exclude minority clients from desirable forms of psychological treatment (Atkinson, 1985).

Therapeutic methods. Brief therapies, by their very nature, tend to be time bound, stressing the rapid creation of a change focus and an active, catalyzing, hands-on approach to change (Koss & Butcher, 1986; Steenbarger, 1992a). Multicultural counseling, on the other hand, does not necessarily adhere to Western conceptualizations of time (Carter, 1991; Sue & Sue, 1990), emphasizing being as well as doing (Vontress, 1985). Indeed, whereas brief approaches often seek an alliance within the first few sessions, multicultural models devote significant time to exploring client worldviews (Ibrahim, 1985). Similarly, although many brief therapies tend to be challenging and confrontational (Steenbarger, 1992a), multicultural modalities stress a matching of counselor-client communications as a primary intervention strategy (Pedersen, 1988; Sue & Sue, 1990).

Therapeutic aims. A distinctive theme linking the brief therapies is that deficient aspects of client worldviews--cognitions, self-schemata, and interactional patterns--are responsible for presenting complaints. The role of the helping relationship is to challenge these views and generate more adaptive patterns of action and understanding (Steenbarger, 1992a). Alternatively, multicultural therapies seek to validate client worldviews as part of the cultivation of a multicultural identity (Helms, 1986; Parham, 1989; Pedersen, 1988). Thus, symptom relief and pattern change are less central to multicultural counseling than are empowerment and identity development.
- Steenbarger, Brett N.; A Multicontextual Model of Counseling: Bridging Brevity and Diversity; Journal of Counseling & Development; Sep/Oct 1993; Vol. 72, Issue 1.
The article above contains foundational information. Articles below contain optional updates.

Personal Reflection Exercise #4
The preceding section contained information about bridging brevity and diversity in counseling.  Write three case study examples regarding how you might use the content of this section in your practice.

Ethics CEU QUESTION 11
According to Steenbarger, what is a cause of multicultural client complaints? Record the letter of the correct answer the Ethics CEU Answer Booklet.

 
Others who bought this Cross-Cultural Diversity Course
also bought…

Scroll DownScroll UpCourse Listing Bottom Cap

Ethics CEU Answer Booklet for this course
Forward to Section 12
Back to Section 10
Table of Contents
Top

Building a K-16 Education Pipeline for Global Competence Development - Global Learning - Education Week - January 01, 1970
How to systematically build K-16 partnerships for global education.
Career-Tech-Ed Students Can Skip Exit Exams in Pennsylvania - High School & Beyond - Education Week - January 01, 1970
Pennsylvania has a new law that allows career and technical education students to skip the state's high school exit exams.
Black Caucus Dumps Trump Meeting, Says DeVos Won't Protect Civil Rights - Politics K-12 - Education Week - January 01, 1970
A letter from the Congressional Black Caucus highlighted proposed Trump administration budget cuts and its decision to nix a school diversity program among the reasons for refusing another meeting with the president.
Q&A: Teachers' Cues Shape Students' Sense of Belonging - Education Week - January 01, 1970
Dena Simmons, the director of education at the Yale Center for Emotional Intelligence, says teachers can create environments in which all students can thrive.
Are Confederate-Statue Controversies Teachable Moments? - Education Week - January 01, 1970
Some teachers are using the debates over the removal of statues of Confederate heroes to bring alive lessons about post-Civil War history.

CEU Continuing Education for
Counselor CEUs, Social Worker CEUs, Psychology CEUs, MFT CEUs

OnlineCEUcredit.com Login


Forget your Password Reset it!